do not change into one another. Rather, this is how you see them through your reality with your Lord; this is other than that.” At first sight, or on an initial reading, his words seem to someone without knowledge of things to mean that the column remained stone as before and was gold only in the beholder’s eye. The man then saw it as stone again, just as it had originally been.
(Moses’ Staff and Its Return to Its Former Way)
God Most High says concerning Moses’ staff, peace be upon him: “What is that in your right hand, Moses? He said: It is my staff” [Ta Ha 20:17–18]. Then He said, “Throw it down, Moses. So he threw it down” [Ta Ha 20:19–20], from his hand onto the ground, “and behold, it was a serpent moving” [Ta Ha 20:20].
Moses, peace be upon him, feared it, according to the customary disposition of souls to fear serpents when they suddenly appear, because of the harm to the children of Adam that God has associated with them. Moses did not know God’s intention in this; had he known it, he would not have feared. God Most High therefore told him: “Take hold of it and do not fear; We shall return it to its former way” [Ta Ha 20:21]. That is, it will become a staff again as it was, or you will again see it as a staff as it was: the verse admits both readings.
For the pronoun in His saying, mighty and majestic, “We shall return it to its former way,” would have no referent if it were not a staff while appearing as a serpent in Moses’ view. It is like a person who had accustomed you to something—he used to treat you kindly, and then treated you badly. You say to him: “You have changed your conduct toward me; you are not
Notlar
Translator’s note TN946-1: The author expressly leaves open, at this point, whether the staff changes or the beholder’s perception changes. The following discussion further distinguishes the column account, sorcery, miracles, and saintly marvels. “Entities” renders aʿyān; the phrase “through your reality with your Lord” is explained later in the chapter.
