of the possible being, with these relations belonging to the giver of preponderance, as in His saying, “You did not kill them, but God killed them” [al-Anfāl 8:17], and, “God created you and what you do” [al-Ṣāffāt 37:96]?
Or is the locus the Real's existence, with these rulings being the effect of possible beings within the Real's existence, namely the forms that appear within Him?
Every form witnesses a form, these being the effects of possible beings within the Real's existence. Zayd sees Khālid's form within real existence, and Khālid sees Zayd's form within real existence. Likewise, every state in which he sees that form is just like the form itself.
Each of the two positions has been held by a group among the people of God. Whichever of the two positions is taken, no holder of either can remain firm upon one affair. In the very act of establishing a ruling for one affair, he establishes it for another and denies it of the first. He denies what preceded and affirms what follows.
(The Succession of Negation and Affirmation)
Whichever affair he begins with, this ruling belongs to him in both positions. It is like His saying, “You did not throw,” negating, then, “when you threw” [al-Anfāl 8:17], affirming the throwing of the one from whom He denied it.
Then He did not remain firm upon affirmation. He followed affirmation with negation, as He had followed negation with affirmation, saying, “But God threw” [al-Anfāl 8:17].
How swiftly He denied, and how swiftly He affirmed, concerning a single entity!
For this reason this mutual encounter is named the Flowing Path, likened to the flowing of water, which remains upon nothing in its course except for the measure of its passage over it. The feet of its men remain firm upon nothing
