Those who affirm hold the opposite:
He is the Seer, and we are His mirrors.
(Action, the Instrument, and the Attribution of Killing)
God, mighty and majestic is He, said, “You did not kill them, but God killed them” [al-Anfāl 8:17]. He is the One who said, “Kill them wherever you find them” [al-Nisāʾ 4:89]. Within this address imposing duties He thus manifested a commander, a command, and one commanded.
When compliance occurred and killing appeared in action from the entities of temporally originated beings, He said: It was not you who killed them; rather, I killed them.[38] You stand toward Us as the sword stands toward you, or whatever instrument is used for killing.
The killing occurred within the slain through the instrument, yet the instrument was not called the killer. The one striking with it was called the killer. Likewise, the one striking with it stands toward Us as, for him, the sword stands toward him.
The responsible person is therefore not called the killer. Rather, God is the killer through the responsible person and the sword. For Him, the responsible person stands in the place of the hand striking with the sword, like the Black Stone as God's right hand in the pledge of allegiance: kissing and touching it are like the handclasp of two persons.
(Rulings and the Locus of Their Appearance)
Clarifying this mutual encounter consists in knowing the affairs that necessitate rulings: do they possess existent entities, or are they relations demanded by the rulings and therefore intelligible through their rulings?
There remains knowledge of the locus within which these rulings appear: what is it? Is it the entity
Notlar
[38]
(This expression is the author's explanation of the meaning of the verse with which he opened. It has not been placed within the marks used for Qurʾanic text.)
