which entails acting or refraining according to what the address requires.
Believing that voluntary charitable giving is voluntary is obligatory and belongs to the foundations of the revealed law. Giving the voluntary charity is a branch. It and obligatory charitable giving are alike in being believed in and paid out, even though their rewards are unequal. This does not impair the foundation. Although they differ in one respect, they come together in the stronger respect.
(Belief in the Rulings and Acting on Them)
Faith is a foundation, and action is undoubtedly a branch of it. For this reason, a believer’s disobedience is never wholly unmixed with obedience. The one who mixes the two is the disobedient believer. When a believer disobeys in some matter, he believes it to be disobedience. Faith is obligatory, so he has performed an obligation. The believer is thus rewarded within his very disobedience, and faith is stronger than disobedience.
No almsgiving is due from protected non-Muslims in the sense that it does not discharge their obligation if they pay it, even though it is obligatory for them like all the other obligations of the revealed law. They lack the condition that makes it valid, faith in everything the revealed law brought, rather than faith in almsgiving alone or in some of what the law brought. If someone believed only in almsgiving, or that some obligatory acts are obligatory, or that some voluntary acts are voluntary, but withheld belief from even one matter, obligatory or voluntary, his faith would not be accepted until he believed in all of it.
Nevertheless, we may not ask someone under covenant for his almsgiving. If he brings it of his own accord, we may not reject it, since he has brought it to us unasked. It is taken
