a Specifier (God, exalted is He, the Necessary Existent), this would be precisely the origination of everything other than God.
Question (34): (Time)
The assertion that time is an imagined duration traversed by the motion of the celestial sphere is inconsistent speech, since what is imagined has no realized existence. Those who say this object to the Asharites’ positing time in the case of the first possible existent; yet the sphere’s motions would then traverse nothing. If another says that time is the sphere’s motion, and the sphere is spatially located, then motion traverses only what is spatially located.[196]
Question (35): (The Equivocal Expression)
I am astonished by two great groups, the Asharites and the corporealists, in their error concerning an equivocal expression: how they make it imply resemblance! In Arabic, a comparison between two things requires the word “like” or the descriptive kaf. This is scarcely found in any verse or report that they have treated as implying resemblance.
The Asharites then imagine that, by interpreting figuratively, they have escaped resemblance. They have not left it: they have merely moved from resemblance to bodies to resemblance to originated meanings, which differ in reality and definition from beginningless attributes. They have therefore not departed at all from resemblance to originated things.
Were we to adopt their position, we would not, for example, turn from establishment understood as settling to establishment understood as taking dominion, as they have done—especially since the Throne—
Notlar
[196]
We discussed these differing philosophical views of time in detail in Chapter One of Nazariyyat al-Jawhar al-Fard.
