and Abū ʿUmar ibn ʿAbd al-Barr said that it has a defect.
Continuation: Wiping the Turban Inwardly
As for the inward ruling of wiping over the turban, know that incidental things do not counteract underlying principles or impair them. You should therefore consider the cause that occasions such an incident. It can be something that may be dispensed with, or something whose absence causes harm and therefore cannot be dispensed with.
If it can be dispensed with, it has no force to remove the ruling of the underlying principle. If it cannot be dispensed with and harm follows from its absence, its ruling is that of the underlying principle and it stands in its place. If any part of the underlying case remains, that part must necessarily be observed. For the rest of the underlying case, this incident whose absence causes harm takes its place. This is our position on the matter.
Thus the report we mentioned, which some scholars in this field consider defective, says that the wiping was over the forelock and the turban together. The water therefore touched the hair, fulfilling the original ruling according to the position of those who say that part of the head is wiped. If someone wears a turban for adornment, wiping over it is impermissible for him. This differs from the case of a sick person who binds a turban around his head on account of illness. No report has come to counter the express wording of the Quran on this question.
Notlar
Translator’s note TN1382-1: The criticism of the report and the legal conclusion about the turban are given in the author’s account. The distinction he draws is between an incidental covering that is needed and one worn for adornment.
