meaning the Messenger whom We appointed as Our vicegerent. We granted him authority to command and forbid in addition to conveying Our commands and prohibitions to Our servants.
(Obedience to Those in Authority and the Limits of Command and Prohibition)
He then said in that same verse, “and those in authority among you” [al-Nisa 4:59]. That is, if a vicegerent of My Messenger is put in authority over you, or you appoint him yourselves as has been prescribed for you, listen to him and obey him, even if he is an Abyssinian slave with mutilated extremities. In obeying him you obey the Messenger of God, may God bless him and grant him peace.
For this reason He did not repeat the command “obey” before “those in authority” and contented Himself with “obey the Messenger” [al-Nisa 4:59]. Yet He did not content Himself with “obey God” in place of “obey the Messenger.” He made them separate because He, exalted is He, is such that “there is nothing like Him” [al-Shura 42:11], and began a new command with “and obey the Messenger.”
This is proof that He, exalted is He, has prescribed for him, may God bless him and grant him peace, authority to command and forbid. Those in authority have no right to institute a revealed law. They can only command and forbid in matters permissible for them and for us. If they command us to do something permissible or forbid us something permissible, and we obey them in that, we are given the reward of one who has obeyed God in a command or prohibition He made obligatory. This is God’s generosity toward us, although the heedless among us do not perceive it.
Another question from this chapter
The angels and all creatures were commanded to prostrate, and nearness was joined to it,
