Futmak · الفتوحات المكية · Meccan Revelations

The Meccan Revelations

Manuscript volume 5 · Page 272

Konya manuscript

Open Arabic sourceOpen English translation

English

that is explicit and admits no interpretation, then when you put it beside the latter it is like carrion in relation to a living animal. Since we found no prohibition from the Lawgiver against making use of them, both remain subject to the original principle, stated in the words of God Most High, “He created for you all that is on the earth” [al-Baqarah 2:29]. He drew no distinction between the pure and the impure.

(Tanning and Removing Ambiguity from the Wording)

We may use a hide without judging it pure. Only if it is tanned[42] is it then pure. The inward application is this. When wording transmitted from the Lawgiver admits more than one meaning, we judge according to its outward sense, without deciding with certainty that this is what was intended.

If we happen to find another explicit text on that ruling which removes the ambiguity of the other wording, the first wording is purified of that ambiguity. The second report does for it what tanning does for the hide.

We thereby combine its purity in itself, through the second report fixing it decisively to one of its possible meanings, with making use of it as we did before it was pure. This concerns our use of it in general, leaving the particular use open.

The second report may divert the first from the outward sense in which we had been using it to another of its possible meanings. This is why we spoke of its being usable in general, without restricting it to

Notes

[42]

(The exception was set in accordance with the newer edition, “Only if it is tanned is it then pure.”)

Translator’s note TN1548-1: The comparison distinguishes provisional reliance on the outward wording from certainty about its intended sense. A second text can yield that certainty and may also change how the first text is applied.

Manuscript imageManuscript volume 5 · Page 272

Arabic and English are linked by the same Konya page ID. Page alignment is approximate; consult the manuscript image for verification.

Cairo source reference

Ibn al-Arabi, The Meccan Revelations — Manuscript volume 5 · Page 272 — https://www.futmak.com/english/konya/pages.php?id=1548&text=en