that report knows it—that is, he knows what that reporter has conceived, whether the report is false or true. He has therefore inherited, without doubt.
Do you not see that he, God’s blessings and peace be upon him, said, “Whoever relates a report that he considers false is one of the liars”? For he has inherited falsehood from him, and his ruling becomes that of the liar, just as the heir’s ruling concerning property becomes that of the one who died and left it.
Since he made “the scholars” universal through the alif and lām, His saying, “Until We know,” enters within it. Since he made “the prophets” universal through the alif and lām, every reporter through speech or state enters within it. For someone who appears to your eye after not having been apparent has informed you, by his appearance, that he has appeared to you.
Even if he said to you, “I have appeared to you,” he would not give you knowledge of his appearance, but only knowledge of his saying to you—that is, that he appeared to your eye for your sake.
(The Two Meanings of the Scholars’ Inheriting from the Prophets)
The first, immediate, apparent understanding, which the people of the outward regard as equivalent to an explicit text, is that “the scholars are the heirs of the prophets,” who report from God. According to the second understanding, which the first does not invalidate, scholars are the heirs of reporters in what they report, whoever those reporters may be.
(What Is Peculiar to Knowledge Inherited from Prophethood)
Yet the knowledge inherited from the prophets, peace be upon them, is not the knowledge that intellects and senses can perceive independently without reports, for that would not be inheritance. What scholars inherit from the prophets is only what intellects cannot independently perceive through their reflection.
As for the divine knowledge you inherit from the prophets, it is what intellects deem impossible through their proofs[89]. As for what intellects allow as possible, the prophets specify for them one of the two possibilities, as in Abraham’s saying,
Notes
[89]
(The corrupt spelling tḥlʾh was corrected to tuḥīluhu, “deem it impossible,” by comparison with the new edition.)
