he has an apparent ground on which to rely in obeying his Master’s command after the word—the word of punishment—had become binding upon him, through His words, exalted is He, “Go!” [al-Israʾ 17:63], “Rouse!” “Rally!” and “Promise them!” [al-Israʾ 17:64]. For in that he finds some relief.
Nevertheless, he grieves when he sees the forgiveness obtained by the people of ʿArafah, embracing them all, while he is there—I mean, in ʿArafah. In his own estimation, some portion of it must therefore reach him from the very source of divine favor, even after a time. This is his expectation of his Lord.
As for his leaving Hell, however, there is no way to it, for he and his followers among those who associate partners with God are the people of the Fire with whom God fills Hell. After it has been filled, there is no diminution in it, and therefore no departure.
God commanded the pilgrim to move up from Iblīs’s standing place, for it is the standing place of remoteness. Iblīs is under the ruling of the name the Remote, and the people of ʿArafah under the ruling of the name the Near. They have never left the ruling of the names.
The Hajj of someone standing at ʿUranah, since it belongs to ʿArafāt, is therefore complete but deficient in excellence, as we have explained concerning departing before the imam. ʿUranah is a place where standing is disapproved because of sharing the place with Satan. Do you not see that the Prophet, may God bless him and grant him peace, likewise moved up from the valley floor where he had missed the dawn prayer? He explained, saying, “It is a valley with a satan in it,” for it was he who lulled Bilāl until he slept instead of watching for dawn. The report states that when one of you sleeps, Satan ties three knots at the back of his head, striking the place of
