that cleansing is permissible with anything, whether pure or impure. Al-Ṭabarī alone took this position against the majority.
Continuation on the Inward Application of What We Have Mentioned
If one can cleanse oneself of blameworthy character traits and forms of ignorance by any means, one may use it to remove this impurity. It may be a good trait or another, base trait. It may be a noble kind of knowledge on account of the nobility of its object, or a lesser kind that has no effect on the place except to cleanse it. This is the tendency of al-Ṭabarī’s position, in which he differed from the majority.
Someone whose concern in removing impurity is solely the means employed, and who follows the Law and the Lawgiver’s detailed provisions, acts according to what he understands from the Lawgiver as he seeks to understand God’s religion. People differ in their natural capacity to understand from God, which is where independent legal reasoning comes in.
He removes the substance of the impurity only with what he judges most likely to be what the Lawgiver intended. This is preferable. It applies equally to the outward and inward rulings, which dispenses with going into detail.
Chapter
