Then he said: When a thing exists in its own entity, one possessing an eye may see it with that eye, bounded by the visible face and its eyelid. According to most Asharites, no cause makes vision possible except existence, with or without a bodily constitution; and a constitution is nevertheless indispensable. If vision affected what is seen, we would deem it impossible. Thus the questions have become clear through their proofs, as we have set them out.
Then, after praising God, the Western imam invoked blessings and peace and sat down. Those present thanked him for his concise expression and his comprehensive conveyance of meanings through subtle allusion.
Section Two: On Knowing the Bearer That Is Itself Borne and Inseparably Attached, in the Eastern Tongue
Chapter (2.1): Power
Then the Easterner arose and said: Forming a thing from a thing is a turning; forming it from no thing is the power of beginninglessness. Whatever cannot resist you lies within the effective reach of your power, and always has.
Chapter (2.2): Knowledge
Then he said: The bringing forth of perfect ordering in something perfectly ordered establishes, by its consequence, the existence of knowledge in the one who orders it.
Chapter (2.3): Life
Then he said: Life in the knower is a necessary condition and an abiding attribute.
Notes
Translator’s note TN132-1: The source first says “with or without a constitution” and then “a constitution is indispensable.” Both statements are retained. The precise scope of the latter qualification is not resolved by the supplied text.
Translator’s note TN132-2: “A turning” translates mayl in section 2.1. The terse contrast distinguishes formation from an existing thing from formation “from no thing”; it has not been expanded into an additional physical or theological theory.
