All aspects, therefore, names are not intelligible except by intelligible attributions, and attributions are intelligible only by intelligible the appearances expressed in the world. Accordingly, attributions occur through the occurrence of appearances, because appearances insofar as they are objects do not occur, and insofar as they are manifestations, they occur, so the ratios are an event, so the names are subordinate to them and there is no existence. It has a reasonable ruling .