Who says that when the sun has risen on the day of Arafat while it is at noon? Who says that until he stones the entire Jamrat al-Aqaba? And who says that when he throws the first pebble from Jamrat al-Aqaba? We have previously said about that, which is that as long as he remains to do any of the acts of Hajj, it is not interrupted. He recites the Talbiyah until he finishes it, for God calls him for whatever Hajj action remains to be done, so the response is necessary, and there is no text from the Prophet, may God bless him and grant him peace, regarding that. The ultimate point of what has reached us is that one heard him reciting the Talbiyah after the sun had risen, and the other what he heard reciting the Talbiyah when he threw the first pebble from the sky. Jamrat al-Aqaba, and the other, what he heard, threw a pebble from the last Jamrat al-Aqaba after his last throw, so each one of them believed that he had not heard something like what they said .