Graphic scholars, may God be pleased with them, differed regarding this. Some of them said that the Talbiyah in Hajj is like the opening takbir in prayer. The author of this opinion considers every utterance that takes the place of the Talbiyah sufficient in his view, just as in prayer every utterance that takes the place of takbir is sufficient in his view, which is everything that indicates veneration. Some of them said that it is necessary to pronounce the Talbiyah

because the Messenger of God, may God bless him and grant him peace, said, “Take from me your rituals

and from what he has prescribed